Thursday, February 2, 2017

Outliers

Vs Stasis
Playing Jason is always a good time. He knows the game, sees lines of play that I miss, and creates decks that just don't come at people along traditional lines of victory. This is why a holdover from all the decks I built while we were roommates is my inclusion of Disenchant or Naturalize effects. Every time.

I'm loath to give them up, too, because damnit, that effect is useful so often. Buuuut when it isn't useful it's a dead card and when I play against members of the newer playgroup, dead cards will cost you games a little more frequently.

Overkill is a deck that I made in the "modern" era of my deckbuilding, which means that I recognized that it was a combo deck and anything that didn't enhance the combo needed to be cut. Therefore, no Naturalize.

Which is a problem when you play against a Stasis/Kismet deck. I didn't have the disruption to get out from under the lock, which is what happens when there are no Naturalize effects and Stasis comes out on turn 3. Show and Tell doesn't really help because even if I reveal an Emrakul, if Jason reveals Kismet...well, my creature is tapped and useless.

The question is: do I really need to address that?

The answer, unfortunately, might be 'maybe'. Matt also has a Stasis deck, one that I've beaten because I had answers to enchantments and he didn't have answers to that. Buuuuut.

Do I need them? Or do I just accept that this is the kind of matchup where I have a disadvantage. I ask this question because I know there is no way to make one deck be good in all situations. Maybe I should go even further: perhaps this is just a card that has my deck's Achilles Heel.

Now, if that card made up a broad percentage of my field-or even of the Legacy metagame-I would definitely feel compelled to tweak Overkill in order to defeat this particular angle of attack. However, on the curve, how many decks do I deal with that come at me this way? That's the real question.

Because when I played against Jason's 5C sliver deck, he exclaimed: That deck is fast. That is not an adjective he uses for my decks very often.

I still think it's worth looking at some spells that are expensive-maybe one or two?-but perhaps it would be better to look at cards to help speed it up that were cheap.

Also, another copy of Show and Tell probably wouldn't suck.




2 comments:

  1. Dream halls works great in 5c decks but may not be great with eldrazi. I don't know what they consider colorless anymore.

    Another idea along the same lines is commandeer could be good. Once again need more 5c.

    You could maybe do spine of Ish sa. You could show and tell it into play.

    Nicole bolas would be good if you could manage it.

    Maybe an effect like violation reins.
    Yeah a well tuned combo deck kind of needs to have a sideboard to help it deal with uncommon situations.

    Just a general FYI we have a spare show and tell if you are interested in trading for it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Eldrazi I'm playing wouldn't go well with Dream Halls. Commandeer might be too situational but Violation Reins could interesting, since you can get anything.

      I want to finish opening the rest of my Conspiracy 2 draft before making any purchases-but if there's nothing there, a trade might be doable!

      Delete